Skip to content

CrashCourse Literature: Their Eyes Were Watching God

Author: Zora Neale Hurston · Episode: CrashCourse Literature playlist YouTube: Watch on YouTube Era: USH Unit 2 — The Harlem Renaissance and 1930s Black American Experience ELA Standard: R.8 — Analyze how an author uses literary elements and devices to develop theme SS Connection: US.6_12.4 — Social structures and the Black American experience in the interwar period; US.6_12.2 — The Harlem Renaissance as a cultural and ideological movement

What This Episode Is About

John Green reads Hurston's novel as a story about self-discovery and the right to define your own identity — and connects it to the Harlem Renaissance's larger project of Black Americans claiming cultural authority and voice on their own terms. The episode pays close attention to Hurston's use of African American vernacular English as a literary choice (not an error or limitation), her depiction of Black Southern life as internally rich and complex, and her protagonist Janie's journey as a feminist narrative decades before the term existed in common use.

Key Concepts Covered

  • The narrative frame: Janie telling her story to her best friend Pheoby, and what that choice means for voice and audience
  • African American Vernacular English (AAVE) as a literary device — Hurston's deliberate choice to honor the language of her community
  • The horizon as a recurring symbol: Janie's journey as a search for self-actualization
  • Three marriages as a structural device: each relationship as a different kind of oppression or freedom
  • Tea Cake: a complicated figure — what the novel says about love, risk, and the cost of autonomy
  • The Harlem Renaissance context: why Hurston's approach to Black Southern life was controversial among some of her contemporaries (including Richard Wright)
  • Hurston as an anthropologist: how her fieldwork shaped the novel's representation of culture and community
  • The hurricane: natural disaster as both literal plot event and thematic test of character

Watch Prompt

As you watch, track this question in your notes: Green says Hurston's choice to write in African American vernacular rather than "standard" English was a political as well as a literary decision. What does he say it accomplishes? What would be lost if the novel were written in standard academic English?

What AAVE does in the novel What a "standard English" version would lose Your assessment

This connects to R.8: analyzing how an author's language choices develop character, voice, and theme, and to US.6_12.2: understanding the Harlem Renaissance as a movement to assert Black cultural identity and challenge racist assumptions about Black intellectual and artistic life.

Full Transcript

Transcript pending. This entry is a stub.

Skinny Connection

Studio Ideas

  1. Language as Politics: Students select a passage written in AAVE from the novel and rewrite it in standard academic English. Then they write a W.3 reflection: what changed? What was lost? Connect to R.8 (voice and tone as literary elements) and US.6_12.2 (the Harlem Renaissance's cultural politics and what it meant to claim Black artistic authority).

  2. Three Marriages, Three Arguments: Hurston structures Janie's growth through three relationships. Students map each marriage against the novel's central theme of self-discovery, then write a W.4 argument: which marriage is the most important turning point in Janie's development, and why? They connect the social conditions of each relationship to US.6_12.4 (women's roles and Black women's specific constraints in the Jim Crow South).

  3. Hurston vs. Wright: Richard Wright famously criticized this novel as lacking political anger. Hurston believed her celebration of Black life was itself political. Students write a W.4 debate brief taking a side in this argument, using evidence from the novel (R.8) and from US.6_12.2 on competing visions for Black liberation in the Harlem Renaissance era.

Reading Library: Full entry

Why This Is Relevant Today?

Hurston published Their Eyes Were Watching God in 1937, was dismissed by the Black literary establishment for not being political enough, and was rediscovered by Alice Walker in the 1970s as one of the most important American novels ever written. The debate over the novel — is Janie's personal journey toward selfhood and love political enough, or should Black literature focus on struggle and resistance? — is still a live debate about what Black art is supposed to do and for whom. The novel's depiction of an all-Black community in Eatonville, Florida (a real place, the first incorporated all-Black municipality in the U.S.) is also a record of something that rarely gets documented: Black life as it was lived outside the frame of white gaze, white violence, and white judgment. That documentation is itself a political act, and what it documents is largely gone. See USH-01: When the System Fails and the MLK Letter from Birmingham Jail for related context.

Entry created: 2026-06-16 · Status: stub · Transcript: pending